TripleFact: Defending Data Contamination in the Evaluation of LLM-driven Fake News Detection

The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has introduced unprecedented challenges in fake news detection due to benchmark data contamination (BDC), where evaluation benchmarks are inadvertently memorized during the pre-training, leading to the inflated performance metrics. Traditional evaluation paradigms, reliant on static datasets and closedworld assumptions, fail to account the BDC risk in large-scale pre-training of current LLMs. This paper introduces TripleFact 1 , a novel evaluation framework for fake news detection task, which designed to mitigate BDC risk while prioritizing real-world applicability. Triple-Fact integrates three components: (1) Human-Adversarial Preference Testing (HAPT) to assess robustness against human-crafted misinformation, (2) Real-Time Web Agent with Asynchronous Validation (RTW-AV) to evaluate temporal generalization using dynamically sourced claims, and (3) Entity-Controlled Virtual Environment (ECVE) to eliminate entityspecific biases. Through experiments on 17 state-of-the-art LLMs, including GPT, LLaMA, and DeepSeek variants, TripleFact demonstrates superior contamination resistance compared to traditional benchmarks. Results reveal that BDC artificially inflates performance by up to 23% in conventional evaluations, while TripleFact Score (TFS) remain stable within 4% absolute error under controlled contamination. The framework's ability to disentangle genuine detection capabilities from memorization artifacts underscores its potential as a fake news detection benchmark for the LLM era.