WPSE: Fortifying Web Protocols via Browser-Side Security Monitoring

We present WPSE, a browser-side security monitor for web protocols designed to ensure compliance with the intended protocol flow, as well as confidentiality and integrity properties of messages. We formally prove that WPSE is expressive enough to protect web applications from a wide range of protocol implementation bugs and web attacks. We discuss concrete examples of attacks which can be prevented by WPSE on OAuth 2.0 and SAML 2.0, including a novel attack on the Google implementation of SAML 2.0 which we discovered by formalizing the protocol specification in WPSE. Moreover, we use WPSE to carry out an extensive experimental evaluation of OAuth 2.0 in the wild. Out of 90 tested websites, we identify security flaws in 55 websites (61.1%), including new critical vulnerabilities introduced by tracking libraries such as Facebook Pixel, all of which fixable by WPSE. Finally, we show that WPSE works flawlessly on 83 websites (92.2%), with the 7 compatibility issues being caused by custom implementations deviating from the OAuth 2.0 specification, one of which introducing a critical vulnerability. This is a preprint of an article accepted for publication in the proceedings of USENIX Security '18. 1 https://www.google.com/about/appsecurity/rewardprogram/ 2 The OAuth 2.0 specification distinguishes between resource servers and authorization servers instead of considering one identity provider that stores the user's identity as well as its resources [25] , but it is common practice to unify resource and authorization servers as one party [19, 43, 27] .