The Boy Who Cried Wolf: Adversarial Misclassification of Safe Inputs as Unsafe in Multimodal Guardrails

Multimodal guard models have emerged as critical safety components for screening content in vision-language systems. While adversarial research has extensively studied jailbreaking attacks that produce false negatives, the inverse threat of inducing false positives on benign inputs remains unexplored. We introduce Unsafe Induction Attacks, where adversaries distribute imperceptibly perturbed safe images that trigger guard models to reject legitimate user requests, causing a ''Boy Who Cried Wolf'' effect that degrades service availability and erodes trust. This reveals an availability failure mode in deployed safety filters. To realize this threat under diverse user prompts, we propose Unsafe Semantic Distillation (USD), which aligns adversarial perturbations with distributional representations of unsafe content rather than prompt-specific instances. Evaluated on four state-of-the-art guard models across realistic user simulation scenarios, USD achieves 84% attack success rates, outperforming existing methods and exposing fundamental vulnerabilities in current multimodal safety architectures. WARNING: This paper contains harmful content.