Agent Reviewers: Domain-specific Multimodal Agents with Shared Memory for Paper Review

Feedback from peer review is essential to improve the quality of scientific articles. However, at present, many manuscripts do not receive sufficient external feedback for refinement before or during submission. Therefore, a system capable of providing detailed and professional feedback is crucial for enhancing research efficiency. In this paper, we have compiled the largest dataset of paper reviews to date by collecting historical openaccess papers and their corresponding review comments and standardizing them using LLM. We then developed a multi-agent system that mimics real human review processes, based on LLMs. This system, named Agent Reviewers, includes the innovative introduction of multimodal reviewers to provide feedback on the visual elements of papers. Additionally, a shared memory pool that stores historical papers' metadata is preserved, which supplies reviewer agents with background knowledge from different fields. Our system is evaluated using ICLR 2024 papers and achieves superior performance compared to existing AIbased review systems. Comprehensive ablation studies further demonstrate the effectiveness of each module and agent in this system. Our code and data are available at https://github. com/AReviewers/AgentReviewers .