ProxAnn: Use-Oriented Evaluations of Topic Models and Document Clustering

Topic model and document-clustering evaluations either use automated metrics that align poorly with human preferences or require expert labels that are intractable to scale. We design a scalable human evaluation protocol and a corresponding automated approximation that reflect practitioners' real-world usage of models. Annotators-or an LLM-based proxyreview text items assigned to a topic or cluster, infer a category for the group, then apply that category to other documents. Using this protocol, we collect extensive crowdworker annotations of outputs from a diverse set of topic models on two datasets. We then use these annotations to validate automated proxies, finding that the best LLM proxies are statistically indistinguishable from a human annotator and can therefore serve as a reasonable substitute in automated evaluations. 1 * Equal contribution. 1 https://github.com/ahoho/proxann contains all human and LLM annotation data, as well as a package (and web interface) to compute metrics on new outputs.