The Role of Professional Product Reviewers in Evaluating Security and Privacy

Consumers who use Internet-connected products are often exposed to security and privacy vulnerabilities that they lack time or expertise to evaluate themselves. Can professional product reviewers help by evaluating security and privacy on their behalf? We conducted 17 interviews with product reviewers about their procedures, incentives, and assumptions regarding security and privacy. We find that reviewers have some incentives to evaluate security and privacy, but they also face substantial disincentives and challenges, leading them to consider a limited set of relevant criteria and threat models. We recommend future work to help product reviewers provide useful advice to consumers in ways that align with reviewers' business models and incentives. These include developing usable resources and tools, as well as validating the heuristics they use to judge security and privacy expediently. Background Here we provide background on professional product reviewers, defining the scope of this work. We then discuss existing research on the impact of professional product reviews, as well as existing security and privacy resources to help consumers choose safe products. 1. How frequently do you discuss security and privacy in your reviews, if at all?