Evaluating Query Languages and Systems for High-Energy Physics Data

In the domain of high-energy physics (HEP), general-purpose query languages have found little adoption in analysis. This is surprising regarding SQL-based systems, as HEP data analysis matches SQL’s processing model well: the data is fully structured and makes use of predominantly standard operators. To better understand the situation, we select six general-purpose query engines, from both the SQL and NoSQL domain, and analyze their performance, scalability, and usability in HEP analysis, employing standard HEP tools as baseline. We also identify a set of core language features needed to support HEP data analysis. Our results reveal an interesting and complex picture: several query languages provide a rich and natural query development experience, while others fall short. In terms of performance, our results reveal that many of the database systems are one or two orders of magnitude slower than the standard HEP analysis tools, while others manage to scale and perform well. These conclusions suggest that while the existing data processing systems are viable candidates for HEP analysis, there is still work to be done to improve their performance and ability to succinctly express HEP queries.