Lune

CHI2022Top-tier venue

Reflection in Theory and Reflection in Practice: An Exploration of the Gaps in Reflection Support among Personal Informatics Apps

Janghee Cho, Tian Xu, Abigail Zimmermann-Niefield, Stephen Voida

Abstract

Personal informatics (PI) systems have been developed to support reflection. While reflection is considered an indispensable activity in PI use, how and when reflection occurs is still under-studied. In this paper, we present an analysis of the interactive features of 123 commercial PI apps, revealing that reflective practices are unevenly supported. The lack of features that encourage user-driven reflection, scaffolding for setting goals and configuring data collection and presentation, and consideration of wider implications stand to limit meaning-making and frustrate nuanced insight generation based on lived experiences. Based on our findings, we discuss how reflection is currently misrepresented in personal informatics tools, identify and characterize the gaps between theoretical research on reflection and interface features in current apps, and offer suggestions about how reflection could be better supported.

Ask Lune

Know this paper in minutes, not an afternoon.

Lune can read every page of it and the top-tier papers that cite it, and gives you its claims, its evidence and its limits, each one cited to the paper it comes from. No skimming, no AI slop.

27 top-tier papers have cited it since. Know what they found before your reviewers do.

Questions to start from

Lune can draw on

the full paper · the top-tier papers that cite it · related work

Get the answer

Free to start. No credit card required.

Lineage

  • GPTCoach: Towards LLM-Based Physical Activity Coaching cites Designing Ambient Narrative-Based Interfaces to Reflect and Motivate Physical Activity
  • GPTCoach: Towards LLM-Based Physical Activity Coaching cites Mapping and Taking Stock of the Personal Informatics Literature
  • Designing Reflective Derived Metrics for Fitness Trackers cites Mapping and Taking Stock of the Personal Informatics Literature
  • Tracking During Ramadan: Examining the Intersection of Menstrual and Religious Tracking Practices Among Muslim Women in the United States cites Mapping and Taking Stock of the Personal Informatics Literature
Builds onCited byLeft to right by year; the more cited, the higher.

Cited by top-tier papers27

  1. GPTCoach: Towards LLM-Based Physical Activity CoachingMatthew Jörke, Shardul Sapkota, Lyndsea Warkenthien, Niklas Vainio et al.CHI 2025 · 89 citations
  2. Designing Reflective Derived Metrics for Fitness TrackersMarit Bentvelzen, Jasmin Niess, Pawel W. WozniakUbiComp 2023 · 54 citations
  3. Stakeholder-Centered AI Design: Co-Designing Worker Tools with Gig Workers through Data ProbesAngie Zhang, Alexander Boltz, Jonathan Lynn, Chun Wei Wang et al.CHI 2023 · 48 citations
  4. MindScape Study: Integrating LLM and Behavioral Sensing for Personalized AI-Driven Journaling ExperiencesSubigya Nepal, Arvind Pillai, William Campbell, Talie Massachi et al.UbiComp 2025 · 45 citations
  5. Tracking During Ramadan: Examining the Intersection of Menstrual and Religious Tracking Practices Among Muslim Women in the United StatesZaidat Ibrahim, Novia Nurain, James ClawsonCHI 2024 · 28 citations

Builds on12

  1. Mapping and Taking Stock of the Personal Informatics LiteratureDaniel A. Epstein, Clara Marques Caldeira, Mayara Costa Figueiredo, Xi Lu et al.UbiComp 2021 · 223 citations
  2. Trackly: A Customisable and Pictorial Self-Tracking App to Support Agency in Multiple Sclerosis Self-CareAmid Ayobi, Paul Marshall, Anna L. CoxCHI 2020 · 107 citations
  3. Designing for Emotional Well-being: Integrating Persuasion and Customization into Mental Health TechnologiesRenwen Zhang, Kathryn E. Ringland, Melina Paan, David C. Mohr et al.CHI 2021 · 76 citations
  4. Designing Ambient Narrative-Based Interfaces to Reflect and Motivate Physical ActivityElizabeth L. Murnane, Xin Jiang, Anna Kong, Michelle Park et al.CHI 2020 · 73 citations
  5. From Reflection to Action: Combining Machine Learning with Expert Knowledge for Nutrition Goal RecommendationsElliot G. Mitchell, Elizabeth M. Heitkemper, Marissa Burgermaster, Matthew E. Levine et al.CHI 2021 · 70 citations

Related papers

  1. The Technology-Mediated Reflection Model: Barriers and Assistance in Data-Driven ReflectionMarit Bentvelzen, Jasmin Niess, Pawel W. WozniakCHI 2021 · 46 citations
  2. Revisiting Reflection in HCI: Four Design Resources for Technologies that Support ReflectionMarit Bentvelzen, Pawel W. Wozniak, Pia S. F. Herbes, Evropi Stefanidi et al.UbiComp 2022 · 135 citations
  3. How Instructional Data Physicalisation Fosters Reflection in Personal InformaticsMarit Bentvelzen, Julia Dominiak, Jasmin Niess, Frederique Henraat et al.CHI 2023 · 18 citations
  4. What do Teens Make of Personal Informatics?: Young People's Responses to Self-Tracking Practices for Self-Determined MotivesKyrill Potapov, Asimina Vasalou, Victor R. Lee, Paul MarshallCHI 2021 · 23 citations
  5. Understanding and Supporting Self-Tracking App SelectionJong Ho Lee, Jessica Schroeder, Daniel A. EpsteinUbiComp 2022 · 21 citations
Dusk over the sea between two cliffs drawn in fine vertical lines