Zero-Overhead Lexical Effect Handlers

Exception handlers-and effect handlers more generally-are language mechanisms for structured nonlocal control flow. A recent trend in language-design research has introduced lexically scoped handlers, which address a modularity problem with dynamic scoping. While dynamically scoped handlers allow zero-overhead implementations when no effects are raised, existing implementations of lexically scoped handlers require programs to pay a cost just for having handlers in the lexical context.

In this paper, we present a novel approach to implementing lexically scoped handlers of exceptional effects. It satisfies the zero-overhead principle-a property otherwise met by most modern compilers supporting dynamically scoped exception handlers. The key idea is a type-directed translation that emits information indicating how handlers come into the lexical context. This information guides the runtime in walking the stack to locate the right handler. Crucially, no reified lexical identifiers of handlers are needed, and mainline code is not slowed down by the presence of handlers in the program text.

We formalize the essential aspects of this compilation scheme and prove it correct. We integrate our approach into the Lexa language, allowing the compilation strategy to be customized for each declared effect based on its expected invocation rate. Empirical results suggest that the new Lexa compiler reduces run-time overhead in low-effect or no-effect scenarios while preserving competitive performance for effect-heavy workloads.