"It would probably turn into a social faux-pas": Users' and Bystanders' Preferences of Privacy Awareness Mechanisms in Smart Homes
Parth Kirankumar Thakkar, Shijing He, Shiyu Xu, Danny Yuxing Huang, Yaxing Yao
Abstract
The opaque data practices in smart home devices have raised significant privacy concerns for smart home users and bystanders. One way to learn about the data practices is through privacy-related notifications. However, how to deliver these notifications to users and bystanders and increase their awareness of data practices is not clear. We surveyed 136 users and 123 bystanders to understand their preferences of receiving privacy-related notifications in smart homes. We further collected their responses to four mechanisms that improve privacy awareness (e.g., Data Dashboard) as well as their selections of mechanisms in four different scenarios (e.g., friend visiting). Our results showed the pros and cons of each privacy awareness mechanism, e.g., Data Dashboard can help reduce bystanders’ dependence on users. We also found some unique benefits of each mechanism (e.g., Ambient Light could provide unobtrusive privacy awareness). We summarized four key design dimensions for future privacy awareness mechanisms design.
Ask Lune
Know this paper in minutes, not an afternoon.
Lune can read every page of it and the top-tier papers that cite it, and gives you its claims, its evidence and its limits, each one cited to the paper it comes from. No skimming, no AI slop.
18 top-tier papers have cited it since. Know what they found before your reviewers do.
Lune can draw on
the full paper · the top-tier papers that cite it · related work
Free to start. No credit card required.
Lineage
- Raising Awareness of Location Information Vulnerabilities in Social Media Photos using LLMs cites A Design Space for Privacy Choices: Towards Meaningful Privacy Control in the Internet of Things
- More than just informed: The importance of consent facets in smart homes cites Tangible Privacy: Towards User-Centric Sensor Designs for Bystander Privacy
- Bring Privacy To The Table: Interactive Negotiation for Privacy Settings of Shared Sensing Devices cites A Design Space for Privacy Choices: Towards Meaningful Privacy Control in the Internet of Things
- Bring Privacy To The Table: Interactive Negotiation for Privacy Settings of Shared Sensing Devices cites Ask the Experts: What Should Be on an IoT Privacy and Security Label?
- Bring Privacy To The Table: Interactive Negotiation for Privacy Settings of Shared Sensing Devices cites Tangible Privacy: Towards User-Centric Sensor Designs for Bystander Privacy
- Ask the Experts: What Should Be on an IoT Privacy and Security Label? cites Informing the Design of a Personalized Privacy Assistant for the Internet of Things
- Understanding and Mitigating Technology-Facilitated Privacy Violations in the Physical World cites A Design Space for Privacy Choices: Towards Meaningful Privacy Control in the Internet of Things
- Understanding and Mitigating Technology-Facilitated Privacy Violations in the Physical World cites Ask the Experts: What Should Be on an IoT Privacy and Security Label?
- Understanding and Mitigating Technology-Facilitated Privacy Violations in the Physical World cites Informing the Design of a Personalized Privacy Assistant for the Internet of Things
- Decide Yourself or Delegate - User Preferences Regarding the Autonomy of Personal Privacy Assistants in Private IoT-Equipped Environments cites Understanding and Mitigating Technology-Facilitated Privacy Violations in the Physical World
- Decide Yourself or Delegate - User Preferences Regarding the Autonomy of Personal Privacy Assistants in Private IoT-Equipped Environments cites Informing the Design of a Personalized Privacy Assistant for the Internet of Things
Cited by top-tier papers18
- Bring Privacy To The Table: Interactive Negotiation for Privacy Settings of Shared Sensing DevicesHaozhe Zhou, Mayank Goel, Yuvraj AgarwalCHI 2024 · 19 citations
- More than just informed: The importance of consent facets in smart homesYi-Shyuan Chiang, Omar Khan, Adam Bates, Camille CobbCHI 2024 · 12 citations
- Decide Yourself or Delegate - User Preferences Regarding the Autonomy of Personal Privacy Assistants in Private IoT-Equipped EnvironmentsKarola Marky, Alina Stöver, Sarah Prange, Kira Bleck et al.CHI 2024 · 12 citations
- Raising Awareness of Location Information Vulnerabilities in Social Media Photos using LLMsYing Ma, Shiquan Zhang, Dongju Yang, Zhanna Sarsenbayeva et al.CHI 2025 · 11 citations
- Understanding and Mitigating Technology-Facilitated Privacy Violations in the Physical WorldMaximiliane Windl, Verena Winterhalter, Albrecht Schmidt, Sven MayerCHI 2023 · 10 citations
Builds on6
- Ask the Experts: What Should Be on an IoT Privacy and Security Label?Pardis Emami Naeini, Yuvraj Agarwal, Lorrie Faith Cranor, Hanan HibshiS&P 2020 · 195 citations
- IoT Inspector: Crowdsourcing Labeled Network Traffic from Smart Home Devices at ScaleDanny Yuxing Huang, Noah J. Apthorpe, Frank Li, Gunes Acar et al.UbiComp 2020 · 171 citations
- Tangible Privacy: Towards User-Centric Sensor Designs for Bystander PrivacyImtiaz Ahmad, Rosta Farzan, Apu Kapadia, Adam J. LeeCSCW 2020 · 121 citations
- A Design Space for Privacy Choices: Towards Meaningful Privacy Control in the Internet of ThingsYuanyuan Feng, Yaxing Yao, Norman M. SadehCHI 2021 · 114 citations
- Informing the Design of a Personalized Privacy Assistant for the Internet of ThingsJessica Colnago, Yuanyuan Feng, Tharangini Palanivel, Sarah Pearman et al.CHI 2020 · 103 citations
Related papers
- User-Centric Privacy Controls for Smart HomesChola Chhetri, Vivian Genaro MottiCSCW 2022 · 38 citations
- Exploring the Negotiation Behaviors of Owners and Bystanders over Data Practices of Smart Home DevicesAhmed Alshehri, Eugin Pahk, Joseph Spielman, Jacob T. Parker et al.CHI 2023 · 17 citations
- Exploring the Needs of Users for Supporting Privacy-Protective Behaviors in Smart HomesHaojian Jin, Boyuan Guo, Rituparna Roychoudhury, Yaxing Yao et al.CHI 2022 · 48 citations
- PrivacyHub: A Functional Tangible and Digital Ecosystem for Interoperable Smart Home Privacy Awareness and ControlMaximiliane Windl, Philipp Thalhammer, David Müller, Albrecht Schmidt et al.CHI 2025 · 4 citations
- Investigating Bystander Privacy in Chinese Smart Home AppsShijing He, Xuchen Wang, Yaxiong Lei, Chi Zhang et al.CHI 2026 · 1 citation
